Around the Concept of Health and Disease. A Dialogue between Medicine, Literature and Philosophy

  • Agustín Hidalgo Balsera
    Universidad de Oviedo
  • María González-García
    Universidad de Oviedo
  • Sara González-Rodríguez
    Universidad de Oviedo
  • Javier Bordallo-Landa
    Universidad de Oviedo

Abstract

A problem of medicine is the epistemic uncertainties that are inherent to it, due to its both conceptual elaboration methods and those it takes from the natural and social sciences on which they are based on. Consequently, medicine is not a science, although its basis are scientifically increasing. Given that there are biological, psychological and sociological aspects in medicine in general, and in the concepts of health and disease, and in the reality of patients, there is nothing special about invoking philosophy and literature for the elaboration of theories of medicine. In the present article we consider some of these approaches, the limitations of the biological and reductionist conception of medicine are highlighted and it is estimated that it acquires greater explanatory power of the concepts of health and disease when the human and social aspects of theory and medicine are considered. In addition, literature provides a social image of medicine and of patients that we should integrate into the concepts of health, disease and patient. Finally, we draw attention to a process that seems to have disappeared from medical practice, such as convalescence and the need for a total restoration of health due to the risk, as the Hippocratic aphorism warns, that the residues that remain from disease, relapse often occurs.
  • Referencias
  • Cómo citar
  • Del mismo autor
  • Métricas
Ortega y Gasset. La misión de la universidad y otros ensayos sobre educación y pedagogía. Madrid: Alianza Editorial; 1999.

Briceño MA. Epistemología y medicina compleja. Madrid: Medicrit; 2005.

Bunge M. Cápsulas. Madrid: Gedisa; 2003.

Szczeklik A. Catarsis. Barcelona: Acantilado; 2010.

Saborido C. Filosofía de la medicina. Madrid: Tecnos; 2020.

Canguilhem G. Escritos sobre la medicina. Buenos Aires: Amorrortu; 2004.

Cesana G. El oficio de curar. Madrid: Encuentro; 2007.

Sampedro JL y Fuster V. La ciencia y la vida. Barcelona: De Bolsillo; 2016.

Bernard C. Introducción al estudio de la medicina experimental. Barcelona: Fontanella; 1976.

Gracia Armendáriz J. Diario del hombre pálido. Madrid: Demipage; 2010.

Gil Villa F. La cara social del cáncer. Barcelona: Octaedro; 2012.

Sontag S. El Sida y sus metáforas. En La enfermedad y sus metáforas. Barcelona: De Bolsillo; 2011.

Sacks O. Despertares. Barcelona: Anagrama; 2005.

Puértolas S. Con mi madre. Barcelona: Anagrama; 2011.

Bauman Z. Vida líquida. Barcelona: Austral; 2012.

Bauman Z. Vida de consumo. Madrid: Fondo de cultura económica; 2010.

Valero V. Enfermos antiguos. Cáceres: Periférica; 2020.

Neuman A. Hablar solos. Madrid: Santillana; 2012.

Levy M de A. Enfermedad, dolor y muerte en dos novelas españolas del siglo XXI. Acta Lit. 2014; (49): 105-122.

Martínez Passarge ML. Poética del cuerpo enfermo. Revista de poesía Alforja 2004; 31: 1-3.

Jovell A. El médico social. Barcelona: Prateus: 2012.

Allué, M. El paciente inquieto. Barcelona: Ediciones Bellaterra; 2013.

Lagrée J. El médico, el enfermo y el filósofo. Madrid: La esfera de los libros; 2004.

Aldecoa J. Convalecencia y creación. En VVAA. Con otra mirada. Una visión de la enfermedad desde la literatura y el humanismo. Madrid: Taurus; 2000. pp.19-30.

Hermosín Bono MA. Tratados Hipocráticos. Madrid: Alianza Editorial; 1996.
Hidalgo Balsera, A., González-García, M., González-Rodríguez, S., & Bordallo-Landa, J. (2022). Around the Concept of Health and Disease. A Dialogue between Medicine, Literature and Philosophy. Journal of Medicine and Movies, 18(4), 377–390. https://doi.org/10.14201/rmc.30624

Most read articles by the same author(s)

1 2 > >> 

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.
+