Evaluation reports
EVALUATION PROTOCOL
- The relevance of the title with respect to content of the article
- The structure and content of the summary and keywords
- The structure, organisation and development of the article
- Appeal and originality of the exploration of the theme
- Bibliographic references: relevance and recency
- Antecedents: a revision of the corresponding literature
- Work methodology
- Results and conclusions: contribution to scientific knowledge
- Formal aspects: redaction, clarity, rigour, concept
- Overall evaluation
FINAL EVALUATION
A.- Ready for publication (with minor changes)
B.- Publishable with corrections and suggested improvements
C.- Not publishable, for reasons indicated
MODIFICATIONS, CORRECTIONS AND SUGGESTIONS (in the event of A or B)
REASON FOR THE DECISION (in the event of C)